trrenter_IHB
New member
[quote author="EvaLSeraphim" date=1249516718][quote author="trrenter" date=1249515314]<strong>Now I didn't use 911 as a justification for anything.</strong> I said that it could have been Avoided if Clinton had taken Bin Laden out after the USS Cole attack.</blockquote>
<em>*Crap. In for a penny, in for a pound, I guess.*</em>
I am less sure about the cause and effect relationship of the removal of bin Laden on the ability of the Taliban / Al Qaeda to survive. The Taliban existed before bin Laden's ascendence in the organization, and its independent cell-like structure allow it to survive even as individual people and cells are picked off. Certainly bin Laden's money helped the Taliban / Al Qaeda (as did the US's), but it appears that they also get funding from other ventures (e.g., the sale of drugs and gems).
Also please recall that the causes of the September 11th terrorist attacks were studied by a bi-partisan Congressional commission that produced a voluminous report. I doubt that would have been necessary if the facile explanation of "It was all Bill Clinton's fault" was accurate.</blockquote>
I am not positive that 911 could have been avoided had Bin Laden been taken out either. It is evident that even though they are on the run they can still plan some attacks.
I do not Blame 911 solely on Bill Clinton I should have used the word "could" have averted. I do truly believe that more should have been done after the USS Cole attack. If you read the article I posted there is agreement there. There is absolutely no way to prove conclusively that had we not gone after Bin Laden that these attacks would not have occured. But it is harder to plan the attacks while you are runing and hiding with a million dollar bounty on your head.
My point is that certain people on this Board excuse and Justify everything Obama is donng by pointing out that it only needs to be done because of the last 8 years.
Some of the events from the previous 8 years are a continuation of what started say 12 years ago, 20 years ago even 100 years ago.
So if the standard response to anything Obama does is well it is all Bush's fault I will start responding it is all Clintons fault. Hell maybe I will blame George Washington.
<em>*Crap. In for a penny, in for a pound, I guess.*</em>
I am less sure about the cause and effect relationship of the removal of bin Laden on the ability of the Taliban / Al Qaeda to survive. The Taliban existed before bin Laden's ascendence in the organization, and its independent cell-like structure allow it to survive even as individual people and cells are picked off. Certainly bin Laden's money helped the Taliban / Al Qaeda (as did the US's), but it appears that they also get funding from other ventures (e.g., the sale of drugs and gems).
Also please recall that the causes of the September 11th terrorist attacks were studied by a bi-partisan Congressional commission that produced a voluminous report. I doubt that would have been necessary if the facile explanation of "It was all Bill Clinton's fault" was accurate.</blockquote>
I am not positive that 911 could have been avoided had Bin Laden been taken out either. It is evident that even though they are on the run they can still plan some attacks.
I do not Blame 911 solely on Bill Clinton I should have used the word "could" have averted. I do truly believe that more should have been done after the USS Cole attack. If you read the article I posted there is agreement there. There is absolutely no way to prove conclusively that had we not gone after Bin Laden that these attacks would not have occured. But it is harder to plan the attacks while you are runing and hiding with a million dollar bounty on your head.
My point is that certain people on this Board excuse and Justify everything Obama is donng by pointing out that it only needs to be done because of the last 8 years.
Some of the events from the previous 8 years are a continuation of what started say 12 years ago, 20 years ago even 100 years ago.
So if the standard response to anything Obama does is well it is all Bush's fault I will start responding it is all Clintons fault. Hell maybe I will blame George Washington.