irvinehomeowner said:Other than bones, Farmmie and maybe qwerminority, I don't think many of the TI members have Ivy aspirations for their kids.
I don't... I need my kids to stay home and take care of me while I age into oblivion.
I'm addressing IHS' post.bones said:irvinehomeowner said:Other than bones, Farmmie and maybe qwerminority, I don't think many of the TI members have Ivy aspirations for their kids.
I don't... I need my kids to stay home and take care of me while I age into oblivion.
Haha. Not to get super technical here but what does "ivy aspirations" really mean? I don't NEED or WANT my kid to go to harvard, but I'm going to set my kid up so if by 0.000001% chance, the kid has the smarts/desire to go & gets accepted, the kid can. Maybe your kids are older and you know they're too dumb for harvard so that's your mindset? Or are you saying even if Harvard was the absolute right fit for them, you wouldn't send them b/c you have no "ivy aspirations". Besides who cares if you have no ivy aspirations? Shouldn't it be the kid that does or does not since they would be the ones going or not going?
irvinehomeowner said:I'm addressing IHS' post.bones said:irvinehomeowner said:Other than bones, Farmmie and maybe qwerminority, I don't think many of the TI members have Ivy aspirations for their kids.
I don't... I need my kids to stay home and take care of me while I age into oblivion.
Haha. Not to get super technical here but what does "ivy aspirations" really mean? I don't NEED or WANT my kid to go to harvard, but I'm going to set my kid up so if by 0.000001% chance, the kid has the smarts/desire to go & gets accepted, the kid can. Maybe your kids are older and you know they're too dumb for harvard so that's your mindset? Or are you saying even if Harvard was the absolute right fit for them, you wouldn't send them b/c you have no "ivy aspirations". Besides who cares if you have no ivy aspirations? Shouldn't it be the kid that does or does not since they would be the ones going or not going?
I think he's assuming that parents put their kids into Montessori, Irvine schools and SAT Prep course because they think it's the best chance for their kids to get into an Ivy.
I just think they do it because they want their kids to have the best and safest education possible. If it gets them into an Ivy, that's fine, but I don't think anyone here feels it's going to guarantee them a path into New England's finest.
Personally, I don't find the value in an Ivy but that's because my career doesn't really require that pedigree. But if my kids were to pursue something that an Ivy education would benefit, we would address that during that time. So, yes, it does depend on what they want too.
As for who cares, read IHS' post... he does. And he thinks that a large portion of TI members do too... but I don't think that's the case.
irvinehomeowner said:Other than bones, Farmmie and maybe qwerminority, I don't think many of the TI members have Ivy aspirations for their kids.
irvinehomeowner said:Other than bones, Farmmie and maybe qwerminority, I don't think many of the TI members have Ivy aspirations for their kids.
I don't... I need my kids to stay home and take care of me while I age into oblivion.
I don't like Irvine and I think its lifeless. I don't biasly think that everyone else feels the same way as me.i1 said:irvinehomeshopper said:Be honest to yourself the real reason for most of you buying in Irvine is for the good schools a potential feeder to the top private colleges in the country including Ivies, Cal Tech, Stanford the Claremont Consortium. the colleges located in the East Coast, Chicago and St. Louis.
Trying to be honest and don't think it's true for most parents I know.
Ask yourself: if something was true for you, does that bias you into thinking it must be true for everyone else?
i1 said:I was referring to your earlier comment about the real reason people buy in irvine. I dont think that's right.irvinehomeshopper said:I don't like Irvine and I think its lifeless. I don't biasly think that everyone else feels the same way as me.i1 said:irvinehomeshopper said:Be honest to yourself the real reason for most of you buying in Irvine is for the good schools a potential feeder to the top private colleges in the country including Ivies, Cal Tech, Stanford the Claremont Consortium. the colleges located in the East Coast, Chicago and St. Louis.
Then please explan why Stanford received an average of 45 applicants from Each of the 5 high schools in Irvne that that totaled to 225 applicants.
Trying to be honest and don't think it's true for most parents I know.
Ask yourself: if something was true for you, does that bias you into thinking it must be true for everyone else?
i1 said:irvinehomeshopper said:Let me rephrase that then the most paramount reason is the good schools among many other anxillary attributes why a majority of buyers chose this city.
Do you know how many businesses in Irvine are college guidance, SAT prep, and academic tutoring related? You will be shock to hear the numbers. It is supply and demand. they exist because they are the profitable. AP exams prep guides outsold all other categories of books at Irvine's Barnes and Noble. AP test tutoring are the most impacted for these businesses. Please tell me why parents pay an obscene amount of money for their students to do well on such elected exams ?
Do you know how many florists are in Irvine? Let me tell you a clue: count the number of Chase Banks.
i1 said:I was referring to your earlier comment about the real reason people buy in irvine. I dont think that's right.irvinehomeshopper said:I don't like Irvine and I think its lifeless. I don't biasly think that everyone else feels the same way as me.i1 said:irvinehomeshopper said:Be honest to yourself the real reason for most of you buying in Irvine is for the good schools a potential feeder to the top private colleges in the country including Ivies, Cal Tech, Stanford the Claremont Consortium. the colleges located in the East Coast, Chicago and St. Louis.
Then please explan why Stanford received an average of 45 applicants from Each of the 5 high schools in Irvne that that totaled to 225 applicants.
Trying to be honest and don't think it's true for most parents I know.
Ask yourself: if something was true for you, does that bias you into thinking it must be true for everyone else?
I disagree it's the most paramount reason. Lots of cities have schools as good as the ones in irvine. Cypress YL Fullerton Los Alamitos Cerritos to name only a few but these hoods aren't as pricy. These places also have lots of tutoring and test prep centers.
This has been debated many times but it's the overall package IMO.
callmehere said:Id9510 said:Hi all, we are a young family with an infant, relocating to Irvine this spring/summer.
?We have looked at homes at the orchard hill and stonegate communities, and we are interested in strada (plan 3 with conservatory room ~2,832sqft) at OH (non-gated side) and Arcadia (plan 2 or plan 3 ~3200sqft) at stonegate. ??
We quite like Arcadia model 2, but we keep hearing that OH is going to be a very nice community, and the fact that Arcadia is closer to the reservoir and landfill also concerns us a little bit with respect to health issues and resale values.
?What are your thoughts on the non-gated side of orchard hills vs. stonegate considering issues such as location, communities, schools, and resale values in 5-10yrs? Are there any other communities we should be looking at or waiting for in similar price range? (1.2-1.4m)?
Thank you for your time,
Hi ID9510,
Your choices between the two homes are exactly the same ones I narrowed down to mid last year. At the time, OH had their grand opening weekend, and I toured many of the homes at OH. Messina stood out to me and my wife the most, but was a tad bit out of our budget, so we ended up loving Strada because model 3 had an awesome master closet for my wife. We had our minds set on coming home applying for the prequaification at Strada. On the way home however, we noticed Stonegate and remembered that the developers of Messina had a lot in Stonegate as well, so we stopped by. We were really impressed with Model 2 since the master his/her closet was very large and could possibly fit all of my wife's clothes in there. Also, when comparing the lot sq ft of the home and school district, it was very apparent that the value at Arcadia would be much more than at Strada. Much like others have pointed out already:
Arcadia:
Pro's - Irvine school District (good for practical reasons and for resale)
Close amenities i.e. pool, tennis court, basketball court, Jeffrey Open Trail
Close to elementary school
Lower HOA
Larger sq foot, more value since prices are the same
Solar power standard in all homes
Con's:
Close to entrance of Bee Canyon Trail which leads to Bowerman Landfill - if you drive up this lane you'll notice that it takes you more than 2 miles into the mountain and the site is over multiple mountain ridges and even past the freeway
Strada:
Pro's:
Newer home in OH area (don't really know much about how significant this is but I saw it mentioned earlier)
Gated? I know Messina and La Vita was in the gated communities, but I didn't think Strada was, just put it in since again, I read that in an earlier post
Cons:
School district is Tustin - no knock on Tustin, Irvine just has a better "image" and sometimes that helps during resale
Smaller sq. ft - drive to both again and compare the difference 400 interior sq ft can make.
Amenities are a bit spread apart and I think someone wrote the HOA fees are higher in OH
Either way both homes are very nice, have awesome closets, the extra sq ft in Arcadia does make a nice difference though.