awgee_IHB
New member
<p>ipop - I think I understand your rational, and it makes sense, but I would like to warn you about a vague notion I have in my head and am unsure how well I will be able it to express to you.</p>
<p>It seems to me that there are about 1001 variables affecting home prices, some more relevant than others. And there are about 1001 indicators of home price trends. My observation is that there are certain analytic types, my self included, who tend to want to boil down some issues to a cause and effect situation and simplify them, because that approach works with so many issues. If one can find the real cause, one can determine what the effect will be.</p>
<p>But home prices and asset markets in general, can not be synthesized in this manner, at least not reliably. The factors and variables affecting those markets are too numerous and the relevance of each is constantly changing. Even the indicators change both in number and intensity.</p>
<p>I am a short seller in the equities market and although there are definite common symptoms and issues with the companies and equities I short, I have found over time that each situation is different and that difference is critical to my ability to time the short sale and will to a great extent determine if I will make or lose money. I can be right as rain and still lose if I do not understand the differences. Why am I boring you with this? Because I want to tell you that I think I understand what you are trying to do, and I think it is a mistake. It is correct from a micro view, but a mistake from a macro view, and I think you need to look at a longer term macro view if you are trying to time this market. When I short an equity I do not try and short the top. I wait until I see the trend, both in the equity itself, in the sector, and usually in the overall market. Many times I am too late and the advantage to shorting a particular interest will dissappear before I can enter, but better to have lost an opportunity than to have lost money.</p>
<p>By the way, we sold our home close to the top; not at the absolute top, but close enough so the difference we left on the table is irrelevant now. Buy the macro trend, not the bottom. Flow with the market, don't try to outsmart it.</p>
<p>It seems to me that there are about 1001 variables affecting home prices, some more relevant than others. And there are about 1001 indicators of home price trends. My observation is that there are certain analytic types, my self included, who tend to want to boil down some issues to a cause and effect situation and simplify them, because that approach works with so many issues. If one can find the real cause, one can determine what the effect will be.</p>
<p>But home prices and asset markets in general, can not be synthesized in this manner, at least not reliably. The factors and variables affecting those markets are too numerous and the relevance of each is constantly changing. Even the indicators change both in number and intensity.</p>
<p>I am a short seller in the equities market and although there are definite common symptoms and issues with the companies and equities I short, I have found over time that each situation is different and that difference is critical to my ability to time the short sale and will to a great extent determine if I will make or lose money. I can be right as rain and still lose if I do not understand the differences. Why am I boring you with this? Because I want to tell you that I think I understand what you are trying to do, and I think it is a mistake. It is correct from a micro view, but a mistake from a macro view, and I think you need to look at a longer term macro view if you are trying to time this market. When I short an equity I do not try and short the top. I wait until I see the trend, both in the equity itself, in the sector, and usually in the overall market. Many times I am too late and the advantage to shorting a particular interest will dissappear before I can enter, but better to have lost an opportunity than to have lost money.</p>
<p>By the way, we sold our home close to the top; not at the absolute top, but close enough so the difference we left on the table is irrelevant now. Buy the macro trend, not the bottom. Flow with the market, don't try to outsmart it.</p>