someguy
Active member
JP and his friends have been jawboning about QT since October 2021. They claimed they officially started on June 1st 2022.
"Members of the Federal Open Market Committee in May officially agreed to cap the run-off at an initial pace of $30bn a month for Treasuries and $17.5bn for agency mortgage-backed securities, before ramping up over three months to a maximum pace of $60bn and $35bn, respectively. That translates to as much as $95bn per month."
Source: https://www.ft.com/content/2496105a-d211-4abe-ab5d-46a91876428f
Up to $95B per month starting in June 2022, right? Riiiighht.
Latest Fed balance sheet: https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/bst_recenttrends.htm
It was $8.915B on 6/1/22
It was $8.879B on 8/10/22
That's an average of $16B per month so far.
This kind of QT isn't going to push mortgages to 10%.
"Members of the Federal Open Market Committee in May officially agreed to cap the run-off at an initial pace of $30bn a month for Treasuries and $17.5bn for agency mortgage-backed securities, before ramping up over three months to a maximum pace of $60bn and $35bn, respectively. That translates to as much as $95bn per month."
Source: https://www.ft.com/content/2496105a-d211-4abe-ab5d-46a91876428f
Up to $95B per month starting in June 2022, right? Riiiighht.
Latest Fed balance sheet: https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/bst_recenttrends.htm
It was $8.915B on 6/1/22
It was $8.879B on 8/10/22
That's an average of $16B per month so far.
This kind of QT isn't going to push mortgages to 10%.
OCtoSV said:It's not wishful thinking, just using my brain. QE brought rates to 2%, and you don't think QT will have the opposite effect? What is the mortgage securitization market going to look like when the Fed is conducting open market sales of their $4T MBS portfolio? This has NEVER been tried before. It is much more intellectually reasonable to see rates hitting 10% than just staying flat becuase of the dilution of the MBS market, or should i say re-shaping as today the Fed IS the MBS market.CalBears96 said:OCtoSV said:sleepy5136 said:yeah but all of what you're saying is all hindsight. no one knows what will happen to the market in the future.Liar Loan said:Let's see a first time home buyer could have saved:
-$100,000 in cost
-1.85% in mortgage rate ($15,000-20,000 per year)
-$1,000-2,000 in yearly property tax
-gotten a bigger house for the same or less money
-less psychological turmoil
All by waiting to buy at the right moment.
Holding for the long term does not suddenly transform a bad financial decision into a good one. The optimal move is to time your purchase right and then hold for the long term. Buying at the peak in Lake Elsinore required holding for 16 years to regain prior peak value. How did holding for the long term make that a good purchase? It didn't. Which is why CalBears can't wait to get rid of it.
when mortage rates go to 10% (QT hasn't even started) the timing of purchases from 2017-2022 is going to look much more important in the rear view. The $4M house at 2-3% mort rate will deflate massively all the way to 10%. We've seen this movie before in the early 90s. My parents Northwood house took 10 years to come back above water from their 89 purchase but the $ weren't that big, though knowing your big asset wasn't appreciating was no fun for them. I'm more concerned about the equity markets tanking given how expensive they still are in light of no earnings growth but I'd still rather put my wealth in the market than in RE right now which is why I decided against levering up when rates were at their bottom to get our unicorn house. I'm going to ride our inflation hedges of a 15 yr 1.99% mortgage and subsidized solar/batteries through this multi-year patch of inflation while sharpening the focus on companies with solid balance sheets.
Well, you're wrong about mortgage rates going to 10%. That's NOT going to happen. Just like oil price is NOT going to $300. Both are just your wishful thinking.
This recent Barron's article is a good primer:
https://www.barrons.com/articles/fed-balance-sheet-quantitative-tightening-2022-51659731026