Stock Market Day-Trading Discussion Thread

NEW -> Contingent Buyer Assistance Program
[quote author="blackvault_cm" date=1225448660]<blockquote>

The Four Most Dangerous Words In Investments: "This Time It's Different". Ever read that one before?



I spent years preparing myself for a bear market, reading up on how I should react, protect myself, and how I should reason about the situation. I wasn't very successful in sidestepping the damage as I would have liked (mainly underestimating how even fairly recession-resistant investments would tank), but nowhere in any of my studies did I see anything about panicking and then betting on the end of the world. And yet, this is exactly what I see a lot of people advocating (not here specifically).</blockquote>


No I haven't. But Muzie...if you are trying to truly protect yourself against a bear market how is writing covered calls protecting? That gives you a small cushion to the down side. The goal of covered option is to collect a premium on the option and a small rise in stock price to the point where the price of stock doesn't exceed the strike price of the call you wrote as then its just a wash in theory? In case the stock does go down during that time...its ok...you got the premium to offset your losses...a little. But thats ok...you only need a little because youd be writing covered calls in a market where VIX is relatively low.



If you want to truly protect yourself against a bear market buy puts to cover your longs. And if the market is vicious and volatile...buy deep out of the money puts as Ghamma will eventually speed the Delta up.



Also, I don't think the world will end. I just think too many people think that we are out of this crap and our way to recovery. Its the same thing people though about housing and yet we are still in the mess. It will get much much worse before it gets better.</blockquote>


Every time I have analyzed the married put strategy I have always found the cost of the put to be prohibitive. The only reason I would employ that strategy is if I were a large fund with a position so large I could not bail on a moments notice. IMO, the best protection from a bear market is to get out of it and be in cash. I haven't had an overnight position since June.
 
[quote author="blackvault_cm" date=1225448660]<blockquote>

The Four Most Dangerous Words In Investments: "This Time It's Different". Ever read that one before?



I spent years preparing myself for a bear market, reading up on how I should react, protect myself, and how I should reason about the situation. I wasn't very successful in sidestepping the damage as I would have liked (mainly underestimating how even fairly recession-resistant investments would tank), but nowhere in any of my studies did I see anything about panicking and then betting on the end of the world. And yet, this is exactly what I see a lot of people advocating (not here specifically).</blockquote>


No I haven't. But Muzie...if you are trying to truly protect yourself against a bear market how is writing covered calls protecting? That gives you a small cushion to the down side. The goal of covered option is to collect a premium on the option and a small rise in stock price to the point where the price of stock doesn't exceed the strike price of the call you wrote as then its just a wash in theory? In case the stock does go down during that time...its ok...you got the premium to offset your losses...a little. But thats ok...you only need a little because youd be writing covered calls in a market where VIX is relatively low.



If you want to truly protect yourself against a bear market buy puts to cover your longs. And if the market is vicious and volatile...buy deep out of the money puts as Ghamma will eventually speed the Delta up.



Also, I don't think the world will end. I just think too many people think that we are out of this crap and our way to recovery. Its the same thing people though about housing and yet we are still in the mess. It will get much much worse before it gets better.</blockquote>


First, preceding the Great Depression stocks went up 400% in the previous eight years. People who think the stock market will drop another half because "this will be just like the Great Depression" are forgetting this. There's a reason it was called "the roaring twenties" before the Great Depression. I don't think we'll go back and look at 2000-20008 as "the roaring start of the millenium" by any measure.



As for covered call protection - as with any investment strategy the devil is in the details. As I mentioned before, the premium has to warrant the risk. For me, a 3-4% monthly premium if a stock falls no more than 20% is a great risk/reward (as long as the underlying company is sound!). At the peak of the crisis I could sell covered calls that would grant a 6% monthly premium as long as the stock didn't fall more than 30% (and that was AFTER the stock had already fallen 25% on NO news) - now that was just crazy. I think those juicy premiums will diminish over time - I'm seeing less of these deals today and I have to be more picky.



Buying puts to cover longs is, in my view, is a loser's game if it's done every month. An at the money put for protection till January will cost me 20%. I mean come on - if my stock does a great 20% in this market I get nothing and if it stays flat I lose just as much as I would have lost in a crash. I'll pass. Buying puts makes sense for short term trades, not for investment "protection". Like all insurance-type schemes, buying options is a game where 95% of the people pay more than they event get out of the system.



Covered call writing is a strategy where I wouldn't bet the farm on either a nascent bull market or a great depression decline. The great depression decline, after the initial crash (which I think the initial crash has already happened), declined over a period of many years to its final bottom. In this scenario covered calls with 15-20% protection will eventually turn up some profit as the decline is slower than the padding put in the calls. If a bull market resumes or the market stays flat, 3% monthly premium are plenty good to get an excellent yearly return, even if assuming a 10% loss on one or even two of the months. Not swinging for the fences, and no slouch either.



The main weakness of the strategy is I don't think these premiums are here to stay and I expect the premiums will flatten to 2 and then 1% for the same level of protection at which point the risk may be too high for me.



This is a strategy where I'm neither totally out or totally in. If a roaring bull starts and my stock goes up every month, I will "only" make 3% every month. Geez, only some 42% return. But that's not going to happen - the stock will zigzag and it is to be expected may drop more than 20% month-to-month on some trading action. If the call is in the money 20%, then the stock has to drop... say 30% multiple times to negate all the premiums. That's a pretty extreme string of bad luck (and again keep in mind the analysis is that the outlook on the company is fine, I wouldn't do this on a Ford or anything). Even in last month's crash the strategy would have eeked a 2% loss on the stock I'm looking at.
 
[quote author="blackvault_cm" date=1225448660]

Also, I don't think the world will end. I just think too many people think that we are out of this crap and our way to recovery. Its the same thing people though about housing and yet we are still in the mess. It will get much much worse before it gets better.</blockquote>


I don't think it's over either- but I think we're past the "everything must be sold whatever it is" phase. Future shorters will have to be more choosy.
 
[quote author="blackvault_cm" date=1225453087]I dont disagree with your strategy other than the fact that we are talking about writing calls in a market like we are in right now. That to me is a losers game. If the economy is in poor situation like it is now, buying covered calls doesn't protect you as even sound companies dropped 40-50%. Puts do. Every month? god no...3 months out and then the art of picking the right strike price...but thats a whole book in itself.



I see it from your point of view. Its so hard to interpret though what is right and wrong as we dont know each others full position. I mean if people think I sit here and place bets on puts as my whole position....they are 95% mistaken. Most of my portfolio is in CSCO, MSFT, XOM...same stocks I trade puts/calls back and forth and write covered calls.</blockquote>


I don't really "pick" a strike price. I look for a certain amount of protection for each amount of premium I want, is all. 20/3, when I calculate the odds, gives me good chances. If I would be really bullish on the stock I could go for something like 15/5. I don't really try to predict if the stock will go up or down. I keep my ear to the ground and if something fundamental will tank the company, I can adjust.



Stocks have dropped 50%, but for most that's from the absolute peak. Some amount spreading the calls over time would have helped to alleviate this. There's never any guarantees, whetehr using stops, calls, or whatever, these are all just different ways to trade probabilities.



I think we can both be right :-). Unless you absolutely need another 40% drop in the market to be right :-P.
 
[quote author="blackvault_cm" date=1225453087]

Can you give me an example of what you think is a good covered call? Give me (if willing) a sample of one out today.

Would like to see how you actually price them as it sounds like you have more experience than I.</blockquote>


I couldn't find any I liked today, the premiums were too low for my taste. But, let's take, for the sake of an example, FXI, the China ETF. I would NOT, I repeat, would NOT, do this with FXI right now, because a) it's already up 26% in 4 days and very vulnerable to substantial pullback and b) it's an index, and it's hard for me to vouch for a far away country I don't know that much about.



So FXI is at 25.65 at the close.

You can sell the 21 FXI calls for 5.6 on the bid (you can try to spread the bid with the market maker but that's generally a waste of time).

So the call is 4.65 in the money. 0.95 is the time premium.



If FXI is anywhere above 21 on November 21st, you make your premium. 21 is a 18% drop from here on the Chinese index. The premium is a 3.7% return on your investment in three weeks only (it probably was 4ish percent a week ago).

You still make money if it drops below but your premium starts getting eaten away. You have until 20.05 before showing a loss on your end, which is a 22% drop.



The strategy would have produced a loss in the last month, of course. FXI had its worst month in history. But that only produced an 8% loss, compared with a 30% drop in the index. Something that will be made back by just two months of non-catastrophy. The strategy if you let the odds work over multiple months. There's bound to be a month here and there that shows up a loss, hopefully nothing too bad. And if you're a happy camper like Panda who's actually interested in owning FXI for good, getting it for 20% cheaper might be good enough for you, if that's your cup of tea.



FXI isn't ideal - the premium is right, but as I said, the stock just rose up too much. Plus, the monthly trend could still be downward. Better to pick something which had a drop before, has flattened but is still pumped with volatility. If I had to do play FXI, I would wait till it comes back down, and I would go as far as the 20 calls, for 25% protection and a lower 2.5% premium.



This totally fails if the same stock is hit with multiple catastrophies every month (just like any insurance type of business). But less risk than owning the stock outright either way.
 
[quote author="blackvault_cm" date=1225450572]If you get out...you miss the bull. If you buy puts to cover your longs...You will never miss the bull.</blockquote>


Several months of premium, and you will need the bull just to break even.
 
[quote author="blackvault_cm" date=1225460478]

Now lets say I buy 1000 shares of FXI and sell 10 calls for 5.6. A week passes by, and I sense an opportunity where the market might tank pretty hard. What would you do then? Would you buy puts @ 21 to protect yourself further?

</blockquote>


If you buy puts @ 21 you're no longer collecting premiums - the premiums collected from your call get eaten away by the put premium daily. You're fully protected all the way down to zero but there is no upside whatsoever since you're not collecting premium. Basically this is the same as just selling everything.



[quote author="blackvault_cm" date=1225460478]

Or perhaps selling calls 3-4 months out right from the start and when I sense a temporary dip, buy puts short term?

</blockquote>


The theta decay on the near-month puts would be higher than the decay on the far-month calls. So the premium you're paying melts away faster than the one you're collecting. Not good. I would do the opposite - buy far-month puts and sell short-term calls. In that case both the losses and gains are capped (unlike covered calls where the losses are uncapped). Your premium would be lower than 3-4% monthly though. I haven't looked in the detail at what the expected premium would be, and i fthe risk-reward would be good enough in this case.



[quote author="blackvault_cm" date=1225460478]

What about shorting 500 and going long 500 shares and then sell 5 calls/5 puts? So I create a position where I capture both premiums on either end if I expect the market to be completely flat??

</blockquote>


Hehe ya I thought about that one some time ago. Shorting and going long at the same time just cancels out - it's net zero position (in fact my broker won't allow this - the "sell" command is the same as the "short" command and being short is defined by if my position is negative). It has no hedging effects whatsoever.



But you could go long and sell those 5 calls/5 puts. That would a straddle. A 20% out-the-money straddle would pay a whopping 7% premium for 3 weeks of holding, so could be tempting. The stock needs to go 27% either way before you start to accumulate a loss in that case.



In the original example I was mostly assuming you held till option expiration to collect the full premium. You could buy back the call when it's cheap and sell it again when you think it's expensive. Though at that point the strategy is more like regular trading, in which case buying and selling calls is about the same.



It's a strategy that in my view fits the current environment (no clear trends, choppy trading, oversold but no catalyst for going up, high premiums, little risk premium in other assets). If I was a good daytrader I'm sure there's oodles of money to be made at it in the current environment, but I just suck at it :-P.
 
I am done for the day. I made money.



The NASDAQ broke through the resistance high from the last two days and found support off the 20-SMA. I believe the market is heading higher for a while.
 
[quote author="blackvault_cm" date=1225494138]On a daily note. Dow double topped. We could be going down from here intraday. Or not...



THE PAIN!!!!!!!!!</blockquote>
Agreed, double top at 9,400 resistance level like I figured...picked up 2 more Dec DOW puts. Looks like the funds are getting into stocks and out of cash so they can show their clients they are invested. Low volume is also making this rally smell funny.
 
[quote author="usctrojanman29" date=1225503459][quote author="blackvault_cm" date=1225494138]On a daily note. Dow double topped. We could be going down from here intraday. Or not...



THE PAIN!!!!!!!!!</blockquote>
Agreed, double top at 9,400 resistance level like I figured...picked up 2 more Dec DOW puts. Looks like the funds are getting into stocks and out of cash so they can show their clients they are invested. Low volume is also making this rally smell funny.</blockquote>


Out of curiosity, do you tend to buy your options in the money, at the money, or out of the money? Or does it vary?
 
[quote author="WINEX" date=1225504861][quote author="usctrojanman29" date=1225503459][quote author="blackvault_cm" date=1225494138]On a daily note. Dow double topped. We could be going down from here intraday. Or not...



THE PAIN!!!!!!!!!</blockquote>
Agreed, double top at 9,400 resistance level like I figured...picked up 2 more Dec DOW puts. Looks like the funds are getting into stocks and out of cash so they can show their clients they are invested. Low volume is also making this rally smell funny.</blockquote>


Out of curiosity, do you tend to buy your options in the money, at the money, or out of the money? Or does it vary?</blockquote>
I usually buy slightly in the money puts, in this case I picked up two 96 Dec DOW puts.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top