kcmkane_IHB
New member
[quote author="lawyerliz" date=1220071209]If McC drops dead the week after he's elected, if he's elected,
does anybody here think she is capable of running the country?
Especially when it's in a mess like now??</blockquote>
I'm not choosing sides here (because I think both Obama and McCain are a joke), but I have to say that the Democrats might want to tone down the "lack of experience" chest beating about the BOTTOM of the McCain ticket, because you could argue that she not much less quailifed than the TOP of the Obama ticket.
- Obama was elected to the Senate in 2006, but has spent nearly his entire term campaigning rather than legislating. Before that he was an Illinois State Representative. And a community organizer before that. And he wrote some books.
- Ms. Palin was elected Governor in 2006 (same year), and by all indications has accomplished a lot during her two years. Before that was a mayor of a city of 9,000 since 1996. Small potatoes, but arguably a job with a higher responsibility level than a State Representative. Before that on a City Council from 1992 - 96.
I suppose we can debate all day whether the executive experience of a Governor trumps the Washington insider experience of a US Senator all day --- but who has spent more time *on the job* since 2006? Be critical of the Palin pick for all sorts of ideological reasons --- But I'd be careful of playing the experience card too hard --- because it would appear on paper that she is not too far from your guy in the experience category. And she's #2 on the ticket, not on the top.
does anybody here think she is capable of running the country?
Especially when it's in a mess like now??</blockquote>
I'm not choosing sides here (because I think both Obama and McCain are a joke), but I have to say that the Democrats might want to tone down the "lack of experience" chest beating about the BOTTOM of the McCain ticket, because you could argue that she not much less quailifed than the TOP of the Obama ticket.
- Obama was elected to the Senate in 2006, but has spent nearly his entire term campaigning rather than legislating. Before that he was an Illinois State Representative. And a community organizer before that. And he wrote some books.
- Ms. Palin was elected Governor in 2006 (same year), and by all indications has accomplished a lot during her two years. Before that was a mayor of a city of 9,000 since 1996. Small potatoes, but arguably a job with a higher responsibility level than a State Representative. Before that on a City Council from 1992 - 96.
I suppose we can debate all day whether the executive experience of a Governor trumps the Washington insider experience of a US Senator all day --- but who has spent more time *on the job* since 2006? Be critical of the Palin pick for all sorts of ideological reasons --- But I'd be careful of playing the experience card too hard --- because it would appear on paper that she is not too far from your guy in the experience category. And she's #2 on the ticket, not on the top.