irvinehomeshopper said:
I eat there just about on the average 5 times a year. Joes I have been there much more frequently.
The restaurant is a dump. The waiting area is literally a 3 foot wide hall with at least a 40 minute wait always. The expansion to include the next door space was a hole cut into the wall and a long ramp to connect the 2 spaces with a 3 foot drop. Before becoming successful the steamer basket was larger so the dumplings were not stuck together. Since then all the table have been downsized 40% and so are the steamer baskets to fit on the table top. I hated when the skin tore when dumplings stuck to one another and the soup of the dumpling leaked out. Elbow room distance was a unpleasant experience but yet I returned there many times despite of dry dumplings, lousy ambiance and service and bored to death playing my guitar on the #7 train ride to end of the terminal in Flushing. I did earned my meal with passengers donations on the train.
Joes Shanghai is better than Nan and both are above Din Tai Fung
It might just be my bad luck, but the several times I ate at Joe's in either Manhattan or Flushing, the food wasn't hot enough and the soup portion small relative to the size of the dumpling. Also I always got more flavor from the soup at Nan Xiang. The ambiance and service (or lack thereof) just add to the experience.
Thanks for reminding me of the service though ... being told by the waitress to take my time eating as she was putting down the check and taking away my plate while I still had food in my mouth. Mmmmm...
gld2 said:
Din Tai Fung is the Best ! 8)
Thinking back, I'm not sure what it would've taken for me to feel Din Tai Fung is worth the hype. But going once and waiting in line, then finding out after being seated that the soup-filled variety was sold out, forcing a return trip on another weekend right at opening time, certainly didn't help. At Nan Xiang at least I knew I'd get their xiao long bao eventually, even if they sold out of half the other stuff I wanted to eat.