[quote author="CK" date=1212040984]<em>IPO: "I have been busy running cost-benefit scenarios. Since it will cost me $1100 more to rent vs. own after-tax per month, a 5% only drop in RE prices will end up being a break-even over the long haul for us and a loser for the next 6-7 years. At 10% drop in prices, our B/E on the extra spend is 3-4 years with a net benefit during the years of ownership of $40K or so. With a 20% drop in prices over the next year, our B/E on the extra spend would be less than 2 years with $80K long-term benefit".</em>
I like your math on the b/e rent vs. own. That said, by the description of the rental, it sounds like you are making an upgrade from your current detached condo. Do you factor the lifestyle upgrade into your calculations at all?
I'm curious to your approach, as have been trying to crunch the numbers to justify moving up to a much more expensive rental for a couple years, as opposed to buying now at still inflated prices and just bearing the paper loss for a few years. Ms. CK wants to buy, Mr. CK could care less at this point about owning or buying, and just wants a backyard to flip burgers and drink beer in. I'm fighting the "if we pay more in rent we are just throwing money away" battle with Ms. CK. *Sigh*.</blockquote>
It's all about how the numbers shake out without regard to what we are buying with rental dollars. I can't really factor in the upgrade as its a baseline requirement for the scenario to play out. That is, Mrs. IPO wouldn't consider a pure lateral move as she would rather continue to live in our condo vs. sell it and rent another like it. I think I actually agree with her... The additional square footage, yard, etc. is compensation of the hassle of moving twice, living out of boxes to a degree, not being able to customize the home to our desires. I think those things pretty much net out, especially to the Mrs.
That being the case, it mostly breaks down to the financial pros and cons and also maybe future stress level factor. As constructed now, our master plan would have me worrying about both a new home purchase and existing home sale at essentially the same time. Selling now would reduce that future stress level and allow me/us to better enjoy the long-term house purchase when we make it.
First things first, need to be willing to allow my dog in the rental. Not going anywhere without my Lab!