<p>hs_teach - you'll find that I am one of least bearish types around here, but I disagee with your assessment. </p>
<p>People who bought in 2004, unless they plunked a good chunk of change down, will have their down payments erased by the coming declines. We are already seeing 2004 rollback sales prices. The market value of the home I own has already fallen to 2004 levels and I'd expect to see another $80-100K erased before we hit a bottom. </p>
<p>That means that if I'd have bought my own home in 2004 with 20% down, that entire down payment will have been lost at the trough. Now if everything is peachy income-wise, and people were smart enough to used fixed rates buying in 2004, things would probably be okay for those buyers. Their spending would be constrained some as there would be no opportunity to use non-existent home equity to make purchases.</p>
<p>If these 2004 buyers used 5 or 7-year ARM, very popular loan products by the way, a reset would loom in 2009 or 2011 and there likely would be no refinance opportunity as the home would be a 100% or above LTV That's going to cause some problems. Personally, if I was a 2003 or 2004 buyer sitting on an ARM, I'd be refinancing today while there was still equity. That would stretch out any reset to hopefully a year when some appreciation had re-started. </p>