Macro Analysis of the Irvine Housing Market

NEW -> Contingent Buyer Assistance Program
Trojan,
If Redfin shows that there are currently 838 active listing in Irvine and you are telling me 643, somewhere the numbers are off quite a bit. June of last year the Irvine inventory was at 699, so if your number is correct of 643, we are still within the boundary trend.

You mentioned that 1 - 3 things must occur to see a 10-15% correction in the Irvine Prices. What is your macro economics outlook for the next 20 - 24 months? How probable do you think it is for either 1) moderate/severe US/global recession  2) huge spike in interest rates (above 5%) and/or 3) China imploding to take place by December 31st, 2018?

USCTrojanCPA said:
Panda said:
Thanks for that info Trojan. Is the Redfin inventory data incorrect then for 838 active listings? If there are 643 homes today, the inventory is slowing growing since December of last year.

Date                Inventory
Dec - 2015    484
Jan  - 2016    402
Feb  - 2016    432
Mar - 2016    505
April - 2016    542

So if you are telling me that inventory levels are at 683 today, inventory in Irvine has risen 70% since January 2016. Let's wait and see what happens to inventory by end of this year. My crystal ball is telling me that there will be 10-15% correction in the Irvine housing market by Dec 31st, 2018.

Not sure where Redfin is pulling their inventory numbers from....I know they have a link to MLS since their site will update within about an hour after I've made chances to my listings on MLS.  Anyhow, we are getting lower highs and lower lows on the inventory levels if you looked at it for the past 3-4 years.  The low point will be right around new years day and the peak will be around July/Aug.  For there to be a 10-15% correction in Irvine prices one or more of a few things have to happen....1) moderate/severe US/global recession  2) huge spike in interest rates (above 5%) and/or 3) China imploding
 
Panda said:
Trojan,
If Redfin shows that there are currently 838 active listing in Irvine and you are telling me 643, somewhere the numbers are off quite a bit. June of last year the Irvine inventory was at 699, so if your number is correct of 643, we are still within the boundary trend.

You mentioned that 1 - 3 things must occur to see a 10-15% correction in the Irvine Prices. What is your macro economics outlook for the next 20 - 24 months? How probable do you think it is for either 1) moderate/severe US/global recession  2) huge spike in interest rates (above 5%) and/or 3) China imploding to take place by December 31st, 2018?

USCTrojanCPA said:
Panda said:
Thanks for that info Trojan. Is the Redfin inventory data incorrect then for 838 active listings? If there are 643 homes today, the inventory is slowing growing since December of last year.

Date                Inventory
Dec - 2015    484
Jan  - 2016    402
Feb  - 2016    432
Mar - 2016    505
April - 2016    542

So if you are telling me that inventory levels are at 683 today, inventory in Irvine has risen 70% since January 2016. Let's wait and see what happens to inventory by end of this year. My crystal ball is telling me that there will be 10-15% correction in the Irvine housing market by Dec 31st, 2018.

Not sure where Redfin is pulling their inventory numbers from....I know they have a link to MLS since their site will update within about an hour after I've made chances to my listings on MLS.  Anyhow, we are getting lower highs and lower lows on the inventory levels if you looked at it for the past 3-4 years.  The low point will be right around new years day and the peak will be around July/Aug.  For there to be a 10-15% correction in Irvine prices one or more of a few things have to happen....1) moderate/severe US/global recession  2) huge spike in interest rates (above 5%) and/or 3) China imploding

Not sure where the disconnect is, but I trust MLS over Redfin.  I don't think any of the 3 things that I pointed out are probable.  We might get a shallow/mild recession in the next few years and rates might get back into the low-to-mid 4% range plus China can keep kicking the can longer than any of us will be alive.  Rates today on a 30-year fixed are around 3.25% with the 10-year around 1.60%.  I think the US growth will be around 2%/yr for the next decade (on average)....we will become Japan 2.0 with low interest rates and low growth as the majority of the population (baby boomers and gen Xers) continues to age.
 
unemployment.jpg
 
The Irvine Housing Market will follow a similar pattern to that of the Bay Area. 5 steps forward and 2 steps back.
so7gvs.png
 
There is a difference between a correction to a crash. Irvine prices will go higher over the long haul, but no where the growth rate Irvine experienced between 1996 - 2006.

Continued.. on the "Building One House at a Time" thread.
Link:http://www.talkirvine.com/index.php?topic=3823.195

https://s31.postimg.org/rysqbd14b/irvine.jpg[img]

[IMG]http://i65.tinypic.com/2qnb2x2.jpg
 
Trojan, So you think that 1) moderate/severe US/global recession 2) higher interest rates 3) China imploding are improbable. Can I please hear your logic on why you think these things happening is improbable in the next twelve months?

[/quote]
I don't think any of the 3 things that I pointed out are probable.  We might get a shallow/mild recession in the next few years and rates might get back into the low-to-mid 4% range plus China can keep kicking the can longer than any of us will be alive.  Rates today on a 30-year fixed are around 3.25% with the 10-year around 1.60%.  I think the US growth will be around 2%/yr for the next decade (on average)....we will become Japan 2.0 with low interest rates and low growth as the majority of the population (baby boomers and gen Xers) continues to age.
[/quote]
 
Panda said:
Trojan, So you think that 1) moderate/severe US/global recession 2) higher interest rates 3) China imploding are improbable. Can I please hear your logic on why you think these things happening is improbable in the next twelve months?
I don't think any of the 3 things that I pointed out are probable.  We might get a shallow/mild recession in the next few years and rates might get back into the low-to-mid 4% range plus China can keep kicking the can longer than any of us will be alive.  Rates today on a 30-year fixed are around 3.25% with the 10-year around 1.60%.  I think the US growth will be around 2%/yr for the next decade (on average)....we will become Japan 2.0 with low interest rates and low growth as the majority of the population (baby boomers and gen Xers) continues to age.
[/quote]
[/quote]

Sure, here are some of more of my thoughts...

1)  I don't think we'll a get huge global recession because the powers that be (central banks) can keep kicking the can down the road longer than any of us will be alive by lowering interest rates and/or providing other stimulus.  I think we've witnessed that here in the US first hand with our super low rates and QE programs.

2)  The Fed can't raise rates much above where we are total because the US has way too much debt to service and most other countries are lowering their interest rates and the Fed doesn't want the dollar to get too strong.  I think we have become a Japan 2.0 in many ways (slow growth and low interest rates).  10-year bond rates are down 1% from where they were in 2015 and 30-year mortgage rates are back in the low 3% range.  I just don't see any catalyst driving interest rates higher (aka inflation) in the short and intermediate term.

3)  Refer to my point 1 above. 

I'm not saying everything is perfect and we might not get a recession which will result in small price declines, but I just don't see how we get 10-15% price declines barring any of the 3 things that I mentioned happening.  Loans have been fully underwritten for the past 7+ years since the meltdown and the past 5-7 years of buyers have been stronger and put more money down on average on their purchases (aka less weak hands out there if price declines do come). 
 
Trojan,

Thanks for taking the time to answer my questions. Although I don't fully agree with your thoughts about where we are headed in terms of China, future interest rates, and global recessoin, I do respect your opinion as I have been wrong in the past on my calls before. I would have never imagined that the severe stimulus program would inflate the DOW as high as it has to 18k. As I look at my track record for the past 10 years in commodities, forex, and macro investing, although my timing may not be the greatest, I do seem to get my longer term macro shifts and trends correct and I am very confident in my positions today.

We will have to watch the unemployment numbers in Orange County very closely as this will be our leading indicator.  Once this the unemployment numbers in Orange County spikes, it will have a direct impact to the Orange County housing prices.

USCTrojanCPA said:
Panda said:
Trojan, So you think that 1) moderate/severe US/global recession 2) higher interest rates 3) China imploding are improbable. Can I please hear your logic on why you think these things happening is improbable in the next twelve months?
I don't think any of the 3 things that I pointed out are probable.  We might get a shallow/mild recession in the next few years and rates might get back into the low-to-mid 4% range plus China can keep kicking the can longer than any of us will be alive.  Rates today on a 30-year fixed are around 3.25% with the 10-year around 1.60%.  I think the US growth will be around 2%/yr for the next decade (on average)....we will become Japan 2.0 with low interest rates and low growth as the majority of the population (baby boomers and gen Xers) continues to age.
[/quote]

Sure, here are some of more of my thoughts...

1)  I don't think we'll a get huge global recession because the powers that be (central banks) can keep kicking the can down the road longer than any of us will be alive by lowering interest rates and/or providing other stimulus.  I think we've witnessed that here in the US first hand with our super low rates and QE programs.

2)  The Fed can't raise rates much above where we are total because the US has way too much debt to service and most other countries are lowering their interest rates and the Fed doesn't want the dollar to get too strong.  I think we have become a Japan 2.0 in many ways (slow growth and low interest rates).  10-year bond rates are down 1% from where they were in 2015 and 30-year mortgage rates are back in the low 3% range.  I just don't see any catalyst driving interest rates higher (aka inflation) in the short and intermediate term.

3)  Refer to my point 1 above. 

I'm not saying everything is perfect and we might not get a recession which will result in small price declines, but I just don't see how we get 10-15% price declines barring any of the 3 things that I mentioned happening.  Loans have been fully underwritten for the past 7+ years since the meltdown and the past 5-7 years of buyers have been stronger and put more money down on average on their purchases (aka less weak hands out there if price declines do come). 
[/quote]
 
Home prices in San Francisco dropped 46.1% from the last peak May 2006 to March 2009. Currently prices are at 3.4% above the last peak price of May 2006 but appreciation from January - August 2016 is 1.6%.

Home prices in Los Angeles dropped 41.9% from the last peak Sept 2006 to May 2009. Currently prices are at 8% below the last peak price of September 2006 but appreciation from January - August 2016 is 2.0%.

Home prices in San Diego dropped 42.3% from the last peak Nov 2005 to April 2009. Currently prices are at 9% below the last peak price of November 2005 but appreciation from January - August 2016 is the same as San Francisco at 1.6%

CA_Case_Shiller.jpg


losangeles.jpg


santaclara.jpg


sandiego.jpg
 
Back
Top