irvinehomeowner said:
Wheel of Time I do not get.
I have a buddy who swears it's better than GOT and I could barely get past the first episode... The Witcher was better to me.
If we compare the books, The Wheel of Time vs. A Song of Ice and Fire (which Game of Thrones is based on), then I like TWoT slightly more. TWoT if my favorite fantasy series. ASoIaF would have been in second place if Martin would ever finish the series, but he won't, so I place Lord of the Rings at 2nd place. TWoT is mostly fantasy with some politics while ASoIaF is political drama in a medieval setting, with some fantasy elements such as dragons.
Robert Jordan wanted to pay homage to LotR, so most of book 1 (The Eye of The World) is pretty much ripping of Fellowship of the Ring. Only in the 2nd book, The Great Hunt, does Jordan starts his only writing. Even as a reader, TWoT starts off pretty slow, so I could see why some people get turned off.
Now, about the shows, David Benioff and D.B. Weiss, the show runners, did a great job at adapting the books into the show, until they ran out of source material. So, the first 4 seasons of GoT, which adapted the first 3 books, were fantastic. Season 5 is where things started going downhill. Books 4 and 5 (which happens simultaneously in the story timeline) started introducing too many characters. Apparently, D&D didn't want to drag the show out, so they started killing off characters that are still alive in the books or completely cutting out a lot of characters. Supposedly, season 6 was based on the outline of book 6, which is still unfinished and probably never released and seasons 7 and 8 were based on book 7. However, since D&D killed off and cut out so many characters, they probably ended up changing the story/ending, which is why the final season was so much hated.
As for the Wheel of Time show, I think it's a pile of dog shit. Rafe Judkins, the show runner, probably didn't read the books, because he seemed to have made up a lot of stuff that didn't exist in the books or changed a lot of things. My brother didn't read the books and he thought it was pretty good. So I told him to not read the books so that he could continue to enjoy the show. Either way, the show sucks and I'm extremely disappointed. I'll watch season 2 to see if they finally get back to the books. If not, I'll have to drop it.