[quote author="T!m" date=1256881957]I had a paper route or two when I was a kid. At 16 I went to work at McDonald's for not very long before working at a Ponderosa. In college, I did non-food jobs to pay for whatever scholarships didn't cover. The summer between undergrad and grad school, I waited tables at an Applebees. I learned a lot through those jobs. I learned how to interview. I learned what bosses looked for. I learned to get along with coworkers. I would not want to learn those lessons in my 20s. At that point, the cost of failure is much higher. Better to make mistakes and learn when all you have to lose is a job you don't really want anyway. Oh, I also learned to have empathy for those doing those jobs as adults when they surely must go home exhausted every day.
I know a couple people that are in their 20s and have never had a job. They have tried to get entry-level jobs and have failed to get hired. People doing the hiring look at them and then look at another applicant who has some work on his resume. Guess who they hire?</blockquote>
I don't think work experience alone is the reason they're not landing a job (i.e. economy, social misfit, bad college, bad grades, etc). As someone who has hired staff straight out of college, school, GPA, extra curricular activities, internships, major, etc. is what lands the interview. After that, it's mostly personality, how smart I think they are, and drive/work ethic...meaning good grades and supervising a fast food chain does not impress me. I'd expect that from a jr high dropout unless you actually owned it. When I graduated college applying for jobs they cared about GPA, some asked for SAT scores, internships, etc...all of which would've suffered if I worried about work on top of school, sports teams and friends.
If it was all about tons of non-career related work experience, strawberry fields would be gold mines for headhunters. I agree work experience is important, but you can learn those skills elsewhere...playing on a sports team and understanding your role, interacting w/ prof's, surfing the web to study interview questions, mock interviews at the campus career center and of course when all else fails because you learned nothing by not having a job, leverage your hookups/connections. btw, i would argue most jobs found in your early 20's are not keepers and messing up then is ok.
So parents reading this blog, let your kid be a kid and worry about education and having fun w/ friends. None of my friends worked growing up and even though we were at times ungrateful, we all turned out ok working for good companies at one point...Deloitte, PWC, Accenture, Latham, Reedsmith, Sidley Austin, BCG, Lehman Bros i-banking, Credit Suisse i-banking, etc. And if for nothing else, it'd really help my property value.