The Milessa and Doug stuff is great.
For stickers, buy the better books of static cling stickers.
Reuseable Vehicle Stickers In addition to being able to do them one than once, they're easy to get off your car windows, house windows, appliances, or wood floor.
Not really a 'toy' but, about the price of a spendy toy, annual passes for the family to Aquarium of Pacific, San Diego Zoo, etc.
Xyloplone or pretty much any musical instrument. Yes, it's noise, but it's not a 'noisy toy'. As for noisy toys, IMHO, anyone giving a VTECH manufactured toyed should be flogged. They're the worse, they either have one hardset volume setting 'deafen'. Or they have two, 'deafen' and 'sound cannon'. For added benefit, they're sound tracks are short, annoying and highly repeatitive and continuous.
Collapsible tunnels are a great hit too as you can turn chair cushions and tunnels into a mini-obstacle anywhere.
Toddler garden tools from Lowes are also a big hit. Added benefit on a mini-me helping for parent and me time outside. Pair it with a container garden for the patio and you can teach them planting, harvesting and eating fresh veggies. Plants like green beans, cucumbers are pretty easy growing and most toddlers will eat them. Radishes are super fast growers, but not the popular to eat.
We also have an
artist easel with one side chalk board and the other dry erase marker and a paper roll that pulls over the top for crayons and paint.
I'll also +1 the play kitchen. I do most of cooking and my son will imitate me cooking. We also have a little play grill for outside. He grills too.