What is worse for your FICO? Foreclosure or short sale?

NEW -> Contingent Buyer Assistance Program

graphrix_IHB

New member
Trooper found this from myfico.com, and as she learns the ins and outs of her new computer, she asked if I would post it.





<p><em>Dear myFICO,</em></p>

<p><em>It's inevitable that I will have to let the bank foreclose on my home. I just can't afford the monthly payments and I can't refinance because my home is worth significantly less now than when I bought it. Will this foreclosure ruin my FICO score forever? Are there alternatives to foreclosure that will save my credit? Is declaring bankruptcy better for my score?</em></p>

<p><em>Aaron


Tampa Bay, Florida</em></p>

<p>Dear Aaron,</p>

<p>I'm very sorry to hear about your predicament. Over the last few years we've received a lot of questions about foreclosures and their effect on your FICO® score. The Mortgage Bankers Association recently estimated that 1 out of every 200 homes in the US will be foreclosed upon - so there are many homeowners dealing with this difficult situation. I'll address each of your questions, but limit my responses to our area of expertise: FICO scores. However, you should consider doing additional research to understand all of your options prior to making decisions regarding your home.





Before addressing your specific questions, let me ask you this: <strong>did you contact your lender</strong>? If you anticipate mortgage trouble, we always recommend reaching out to your lender. Your lender may be willing to work with you to find a solution that would keep you in your home. We provide a basic plan for dealing with mortgage trouble in our <a href="http://link.email.myfico.com/u.d?Nmjl0gvANv4fQlVdJ=71" target="_blank">Credit Education Center</a>.





<strong>How will your FICO score consider a foreclosure</strong>?


There's no denying that foreclosures are considered a very negative event by your FICO score. With that said, it's a common misconception that a foreclosure will make it impossible to rebuild your credit. In fact, if you keep all of your other credit obligations in good standing, there's a good chance that your FICO score could begin to rebound in just 2 years. Try to pay your auto loans, credit cards and any other credit obligations on time to limit the effect of this foreclosure.





<strong>Are other options better for my credit standing</strong>?


Recently, several alternatives to foreclosure have become popular - some of these include "short sales" and "deeds-in-lieu of foreclosure". These may be viable options for you, and you should definitely do research to determine if these options make sense for your situation. However, as far as your FICO score in concerned, there is no difference between foreclosures and short sales or deeds-in-lieu of foreclosures. Each of these actions is considered an account that was "not paid as agreed", and will have the same impact to your FICO score.





<strong>What about bankruptcy</strong>?


While both foreclosures and bankruptcies are considered very negative items by your FICO score, a foreclosure can be isolated to a single account (your mortgage account). Often, bankruptcies involve multiple accounts that are "not paid as agreed", so bankruptcies have the opportunity to be further reaching than foreclosures. However, if you're unable to pay other credit obligations in addition to your mortgage, you may need to consider bankruptcy. Here's a post on the FICO Forums that lists some good resources regarding <a href="http://link.email.myfico.com/u.d?CGjl0gvANv4fQlVdC=81" target="_blank"> bankruptcies</a>.





While the reality of losing your home to foreclosure is difficult, there is a real possibility that you can rebuild your credit in a relatively short amount of time. Keep in mind that a foreclosure is just one negative item on your credit file and as time passes, its impact on your FICO score will lessen. From the entire myFICO team, we hope this information has been helpful and that you find your financial footing again soon.</p>
 
<strong>"Recently, several alternatives to foreclosure have become popular - some of these include "short sales" and "deeds-in-lieu of foreclosure". These may be viable options for you, and you should definitely do research to determine if these options make sense for your situation. However, as far as your FICO score in concerned, there is no difference between foreclosures and short sales or deeds-in-lieu of foreclosures. Each of these actions is considered an account that was "not paid as agreed", and will have the same impact to your FICO score".





</strong>This is the part I wanted to get posted. I know there have been several discussions on IHB about this topic.....and some have stated that your FICO will not take as bad a hit with a short sale as opposed to a foreclosure....<strong>.MYTH DEBUNKED. </strong>


<strong>


</strong>
 
<p>2 years?!?!</p>

<p>Wow, when the MSM get a hold of this the banks might as well just close the doors; everyone underwater will mail in the keys.</p>
 
Yeah, that's what I was thinking....2 years, that's it ?? If that's the case, WTF are the FB's holding on for ?





C'mon.....mail in the keys. You know you want to......
 
Trooper/Graphix - thanks for posting this! I'm stoked that, unlike the Democratic party, Ben Bernake, Clinton and Obama, at least Fair Isaac considers walking away from or not fulfilling your home loan obligations "an account that was "not paid as agreed""



At least as far as FICO scores are concerned, not paying your mortgage has consequences and is seen as a BAD thing, which it is!



Sorry - all this foreclosure prevention, loan write-down, homeownership preservation crap has me made me very testy lately. The sooner everyone who gambled, banks and borrowers alike, pays the price for their bad bet and the market is allowed to find its own level again, the sooner our economy will recover. Continuing to cut interest rates and print money in a fruitless effort to provide a sift landing will only make the eventual crash that much worse. I lost $10,000 in my 401(k) LAST MONTH because of this crap...
 
Trooper, you're absolutely right. No matter what anyone writes or speculates or claims about short sale vs. foreclosure or deed in lieu, all three outcomes result in EXACTLY the same hit to your FICO score and they all require the EXACT same seasoning time with respect to getting approved for another institutional loan (currently 2 years). There's absolutely no advantage to the homeowner to agree to a short sale. If a homeowner is headed in that direction, he may as well live in the house until it's sold on the courthouse steps and save his housing money. Anything to the contrary is a myth perpetuated by real estate agents (for listings) and/or short sale investors (purchasing at a discount) who stand to make a buck.



The only conceivable advantage to a short sale is that the short sale negotiator (of which I am one) can negotiate for a waiver of the deficiency if the property is located in a state where a deficiency judgment can be taken.
 
I'm here to tell you that I bet that in short sales, there is at least a little money passed under the table to the seller. Illegal? Yeah, of course. But in fraudulent Florida, I'm sure it will happen, and after reading more stuff here and at CR, it seems that a lot of other places are just as fraudulent as Fla.
 
Back
Top