Soylent Yellow is now is interested in opening a credit account. The only card our Credit Union is offering her is a secured card, then after 12 months a "real credit card".
Sorry, I have to respectfully disagree with this. As you stated, payment history is what matters; dragging a balance doesn't. If the card is used every month, there will be a balance every month and a payment history to match. One thing many consumers unfortunately don't understand about cards is that holding a balance--in any amount--effectively invalidates the grace period. Even if you have just $1 in carried balance, you will pay interest on the average daily balance of all purchases from the prior month.Strong credit is built on payment history. Let some expenses on the card get paid over a few months to show on time payments. Yes, this also means paying a few dollars of interest, but it's a small cost relative to the benefit of documenting responsible credit use.
I completely agree, unused/zero balance doesn't help. I stated, "if the card is used every month", since I'm assuming people have something--anything--to charge every month, even if it's just a recurring cell phone bill. Assuming that's true, then paying off the card in full every month does not hurt, since the balance due is what factors into the score. Personally, I whip out the CC at every single place that lets me. 100% of the points/cashback/credit score bennies without paying a dime of interest.@daedalus
I'm not talking about dragging a significant balance for any great length of time. After reviewing thousands of credit reports and AUS's, I know from experience having an unused or zero balance card does not help increase your score. It can, in some cases if the account gets cancelled for lack of use, be a detriment to keeping a high score.
Zeroing out your balance isn't a "payment history" the way some scores models determine credit worthiness. It's a bunch of zeros to the model. If you get a low rate card and "drag" a $100 balance over 6 months, any interest charges are going to be negligible.
We are talking about a 30-50 or so point difference in a score here. The mortgage rate difference between a 775 score and a 725 score might be .25% in some cases. I'd rather pay $6.00 of interest on a credit card balance of $100 during 1 year than $60 a month of additional interest on a $300k mortgage for 30 years.
Small things done today can yield big differences tomorrow.
I don't even carry any cash in my wallet. I use credit cards for every possible purchase.Personally, I whip out the CC at every single place that lets me. 100% of the points/cashback/credit score bennies without paying a dime of interest.